Should the Detroit Big 3 be bailed out?
So the question today seems to be should the American Government bailout the Big 3. This is a fair question to ask. For several reasons, so let's explore a few of them.
They Did it to Themselves
First, there is the argument that the Big 3 did this to themselves. Partially, this is true, however the auto industry is one of the most highly regulated industries in the United States. Does some of the blame fall on the Government? Certainly part of it does. For example, let's look at the changes in the Diesel engines and Diesel gas over the last few years. Ford, GM and Chrysler have been forced to change thier engine's twice in the past 5 years, the Japenese do not make big diesel trucks so they were left unaffected. It Costs Billions of dollars to plan create and produce an entirely new engine, but this is not mentioned. And, this is one example of many.
Let Them Eat Cake
Second, there is the arguement that they should be allowed to go bankrupt so that they can renogotiate the terms of their pensions and get saved from their creditors. Let's remember it is their creditors that are being bailed out by the Federal Government. GM's CEO Wagoner talked about this idea also, a survey done recently asked the question "Would you consider buying a car from a car company that is in bankruptcy?" 80% of the people said NO. So, is that truly a viable alternative.
Little Detroit or Southern Detroit
Next, there is the newest Talking Point, "Little Detroit". What a great success story this is! The foreign car companies have come into the US and have built plants in Tennesse and Kentucky and other southern states, Honda just opened a new one. They make money selling cars in the US, so why can't the big 3? Anybody making this arguement needs to slapped. These companies came into the US, were allowed to open non-union factories, and with no Legacy costs. This is called "FAIR" competition? Were the Big 3 allowed to go into their markets and compete? Of course not! Could the Big 3 compete on an equal playing field? YES! Make the field fair.
1 in 10
1 out of every 10 jobs in the US is associated in some way with the car business. That does not mean that one in ten is associated with one of the big 3 but, it shows the implication of the closing of those companies. Since the Big 3 sell about 50% of the cars in the US this implies that 1 in 20 is directly linked to the big 3. So let's all roll the dice with 5% of the working population, does that sound like a good idea? Somehow that strikes me as ignorant beyond belief.
Quality
This is a good arguement, if the Big 3 made a quality product they would not be in this position. Since anyone making this arguement hasn't been watching the industry with a good eye, let's keep you up to date. GM has the highest ranked car in initial quality at the moment! WOW! Ford has for last 2 years been ranked even or above Toyota and Honda in quality, WOW! Ford was the only company 2 years ago to have 5 cars rated best in class by JD Powers. They had 4 this year and still had the most on the list. Pay attention idiots!
Been There Done That
Is the car business a good bet? Let's see didn't we as a country bail out Chrysler and then they came back in a fury? How did that bailout happen? They were given guaranteed loans by the US Government and they paid them back early and with interest. The citizens of the US made money on the bail out. Are they a good bet? Everyone thought that Lee Iacocca was a good bet, and he was. I will not speak to Chrysler's leadership because I do not know enough about them, however Alan Mulally and Rick Wagoner are 2 of the brightest businessman of our age. Can they get their companies turned around? They are already in the process and certainly can, given the opportunity, but noone can get credit at the moment, not even them.
Industrial America
We have a Financial crisis like nothing we have seen in 90 years. So do we let our one last huge industrial industry leave? The way we have let the others leave?
Solution
We as a country need to find a way to finance the recovery of the Big 3 (at least GM and Ford). We need to also learn as a government to stay out of the way of progress for these companies. And we need to make all of the companies compete on a level playing field.
Fox Business
MSNBC from the Washington Post